Math 2.0

Group theory and generalizations Proof

Proof that a quotient is abelian iff the subgroup contains the commutator subgroup

Builds on Quotient groupNormal subgroupLeft cosetUniqueness of inversesCommutator of two elementsCommutator subgroupSubgroup generated by a subsetAbelian group

Proof

We show that two cosets commute exactly when the commutator of their representatives lies in NN.

  1. Let GG be a group with identity ee, and let NN be a normal subgroup of GG. The quotient group G/NG/N has the operation (aN)(bN)=(ab)N(aN)(bN) = (ab)N.
  2. We record a fact on left cosets: for a,b∈Ga, b \in G, aN=bNaN = bN holds exactly when a−1b∈Na^{-1}b \in N.
  3. Proof of step 2. If aN=bNaN = bN, then b=be∈aNb = be \in aN, so b=anb = an with n∈Nn \in N, and a−1b=n∈Na^{-1}b = n \in N.
  4. Conversely, let n=a−1b∈Nn = a^{-1}b \in N. Closure gives nN⊆NnN \subseteq N, and each m∈Nm \in N is n(n−1m)∈nNn(n^{-1}m) \in nN. So nN=NnN = N, and bN=(an)N=(aN)(nN)=aNbN = (an)N = (aN)(nN) = aN.
  5. For g,h∈Gg, h \in G, (hg)(g−1h−1)=e(hg)(g^{-1}h^{-1}) = e. By the uniqueness of inverses, (hg)−1=g−1h−1(hg)^{-1} = g^{-1}h^{-1}.
  6. Let g,h∈Gg, h \in G. By step 1, (gN)(hN)=(hN)(gN)(gN)(hN) = (hN)(gN) holds exactly when (hg)N=(gh)N(hg)N = (gh)N.
  7. By steps 2 and 5, this holds exactly when g−1h−1gh∈Ng^{-1}h^{-1}gh \in N, that is, when the commutator [g,h][g, h] lies in NN.
  8. By steps 6 and 7, G/NG/N is abelian exactly when [g,h]∈N[g, h] \in N for all g,h∈Gg, h \in G.
  9. The commutator subgroup [G,G][G, G] is the subgroup generated by the set CC of all commutators. So it is the intersection of all subgroups of GG that contain CC.
  10. If C⊆NC \subseteq N, then NN is one of the subgroups in this intersection. So [G,G]⊆N[G, G] \subseteq N.
  11. If [G,G]⊆N[G, G] \subseteq N, then C⊆[G,G]⊆NC \subseteq [G, G] \subseteq N.
  12. By steps 10 and 11, C⊆NC \subseteq N exactly when [G,G]⊆N[G, G] \subseteq N. With step 8, G/NG/N is abelian if and only if [G,G]⊆N[G, G] \subseteq N.

Idea

The cosets gNgN and hNhN commute exactly when ghgh and hghg differ by an element of NN, and the difference is the commutator [g,h][g, h]. So the quotient is abelian when NN contains all commutators. Since NN is a subgroup, this is the same as containing the subgroup they generate.

Reading path

To understand this page from the ground up, read these 25 pages in order. The foundations come first. The path takes the proofs Proof that a subgroup is normal iff its left and right cosets agree, Proof that an intersection of subgroups is a subgroup, Proof of the uniqueness of inverses, Proof of the subgroup criterion.

Show the path as a graph
Binary operation, definition, no evidence levelBinary operationdefinitionGroup, concept, no evidence levelGroupconceptCommutativity, definition, no evidence levelCommutativitydefinitionIdentity element, definition, no evidence levelIdentity elementdefinitionCommutator of two elements, definition, no evidence levelCommutator of two ele…definitionConjugate elements, definition, no evidence levelConjugate elementsdefinitionSubgroup, definition, no evidence levelSubgroupdefinitionAbelian group, definition, no evidence levelAbelian groupdefinitionInverse element, definition, no evidence levelInverse elementdefinitionProof that an intersection of subgroups is a subgroup, proof, no evidence levelProof that an interse…proofConjugate subgroup, definition, no evidence levelConjugate subgroupdefinitionLeft coset, definition, no evidence levelLeft cosetdefinitionRight coset, definition, no evidence levelRight cosetdefinitionProof of the uniqueness of inverses, proof, no evidence levelProof of the uniquene…proofNormal subgroup, definition, no evidence levelNormal subgroupdefinitionUniqueness of inverses, statement, no evidence levelUniqueness of inversesstatementProof that a subgroup is normal iff its left and right cosets agree, proof, no evidence levelProof that a subgroup…proofProof of the subgroup criterion, proof, no evidence levelProof of the subgroup…proofNormality via left and right cosets, statement, no evidence levelNormality via left an…statementQuotient group, definition, no evidence levelQuotient groupdefinitionSubgroup criterion, statement, no evidence levelSubgroup criterionstatementIntersection of subgroups is a subgroup, statement, no evidence levelIntersection of subgr…statementSubgroup generated by a subset, definition, no evidence levelSubgroup generated by…definitionCommutator subgroup, definition, no evidence levelCommutator subgroupdefinitionProof that a quotient is abelian iff the subgroup contains the commutator subgroup, proof, no evidence levelProof that a quotient…proof
Each page uses the pages above it. The colour of the bar on a box shows how strong the evidence is, and the box also gives it as text. The list has the same pages.
  • no evidence level
  1. Binary operation definition
  2. Group concept
  3. Commutativity definition
  4. Identity element definition
  5. Commutator of two elements definition
  6. Conjugate elements definition
  7. Subgroup definition
  8. Abelian group definition
  9. Inverse element definition
  10. Proof that an intersection of subgroups is a subgroup proof
  11. Conjugate subgroup definition
  12. Left coset definition
  13. Right coset definition
  14. Proof of the uniqueness of inverses proof
  15. Normal subgroup definition
  16. Uniqueness of inverses statement
  17. Proof that a subgroup is normal iff its left and right cosets agree proof
  18. Proof of the subgroup criterion proof
  19. Normality via left and right cosets statement
  20. Quotient group definition
  21. Subgroup criterion statement
  22. Intersection of subgroups is a subgroup statement
  23. Subgroup generated by a subset definition
  24. Commutator subgroup definition
  25. Proof that a quotient is abelian iff the subgroup contains the commutator subgroup proof

Where this leads

2 pages build on this one.

Further reading

  1. Web https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commutator_subgroup, Abelianization
About this page
TagRDK4W7Z3A1
URIm2://RDK4W7Z3A1
Kindproof
WritingW0 stub
MSC20F12
ProvesA quotient is abelian iff the subgroup contains the commutator subgroup
UsesQuotient group, Normal subgroup, Left coset, Uniqueness of inverses, Commutator of two elements, Commutator subgroup, Subgroup generated by a subset, Abelian group
Changed4 November 2026

Markdown · JSON · Edit on GitHub

What this page needs for W1

  • an inventory row: the row of the inventory that the node accounts for (0 of 1)

The writing levels say how complete the text of a page is. They do not measure its truth.

What links here

No page links to this page yet.