Math 2.0

General topology Proof

Proof that metrizable spaces are normal by distance functions

Builds on Normal spaceMetrizable spaceDistance from a point to a setMetric topologyClosed setOpen ballTriangle inequality for a metricMetric spaceInfimum

Proof

We separate the two closed sets by comparing the distances to them.

  1. Since XX is metrizable, choose a metric dd on XX whose metric topology is the topology of XX. Let A,B⊆XA, B \subseteq X be disjoint closed sets.
  2. If A=∅A = \varnothing, take U=∅U = \varnothing and V=XV = X. If B=∅B = \varnothing, take U=XU = X and V=∅V = \varnothing. From now on let AA and BB be nonempty.
  3. For nonempty C⊆XC \subseteq X, write d(x,C)d(x, C) for the distance from x to C. The metric axioms give d≥0d \ge 0, so d(x,C)≥0d(x, C) \ge 0.
  4. Claim: d(y,C)≤d(y,x)+d(x,C)d(y, C) \le d(y, x) + d(x, C) for all x,y∈Xx, y \in X. For each c∈Cc \in C, the triangle inequality gives d(y,C)≤d(y,c)≤d(y,x)+d(x,c)d(y, C) \le d(y, c) \le d(y, x) + d(x, c).
  5. So d(y,C)−d(y,x)d(y, C) - d(y, x) is a lower bound of {d(x,c):c∈C}\set{d(x, c) : c \in C}. By the definition of the infimum, it is at most d(x,C)d(x, C). This proves the claim.
  6. Claim: if CC is closed and x∉Cx \notin C, then d(x,C)>0d(x, C) > 0. The set X∖CX \setminus C is open and contains xx, so some open ball B(x,r)B(x, r) with r>0r > 0 misses CC.
  7. Then d(x,c)≥rd(x, c) \ge r for each c∈Cc \in C, so d(x,C)≥r>0d(x, C) \ge r > 0.
  8. Let U={x:d(x,A)<d(x,B)}U = \set{x : d(x, A) < d(x, B)} and V={x:d(x,B)<d(x,A)}V = \set{x : d(x, B) < d(x, A)}. No point satisfies both inequalities, so U∩V=∅U \cap V = \varnothing.
  9. Let a∈Aa \in A. Then d(a,A)=0d(a, A) = 0, since d(a,a)=0d(a, a) = 0. Since a∉Ba \notin B and BB is closed, step 6 gives d(a,B)>0d(a, B) > 0. So a∈Ua \in U, and A⊆UA \subseteq U.
  10. In the same way, B⊆VB \subseteq V.
  11. We show that UU is open. Let x∈Ux \in U and η=d(x,B)−d(x,A)>0\eta = d(x, B) - d(x, A) > 0. Let y∈B(x,η/2)y \in B(x, \eta / 2).
  12. By step 4, d(y,A)≤d(x,A)+d(x,y)d(y, A) \le d(x, A) + d(x, y). Also by step 4, d(x,B)≤d(x,y)+d(y,B)d(x, B) \le d(x, y) + d(y, B), so d(y,B)≥d(x,B)−d(x,y)d(y, B) \ge d(x, B) - d(x, y).
  13. Subtracting, d(y,B)−d(y,A)≥η−2d(x,y)>0d(y, B) - d(y, A) \ge \eta - 2 d(x, y) > 0. So y∈Uy \in U.
  14. Thus B(x,η/2)⊆UB(x, \eta / 2) \subseteq U for each x∈Ux \in U, and UU is open in the metric topology. In the same way, VV is open.
  15. So UU and VV are disjoint open sets with A⊆UA \subseteq U and B⊆VB \subseteq V. Hence XX is normal.

Idea

Put each point on the side of the closed set it is nearer to. Points of AA are at distance 00 from AA and at a positive distance from the closed set BB, so they land on the side of AA. Distances to a set change by at most the distance moved, so a strict inequality survives small moves, and both sides are open.

Reading path

To understand this page from the ground up, read these 36 pages in order. The foundations come first.

Show the path as a graph
Element, definition, no evidence levelElementdefinitionProposition, concept, no evidence levelPropositionconceptReal numbers, object, no evidence levelReal numbersobjectSet bounded above, definition, no evidence levelSet bounded abovedefinitionSet, definition, no evidence levelSetdefinitionConjunction, definition, no evidence levelConjunctiondefinitionDisjunction, definition, no evidence levelDisjunctiondefinitionImplication, definition, no evidence levelImplicationdefinitionPredicate, definition, no evidence levelPredicatedefinitionInfimum, definition, no evidence levelInfimumdefinitionEmpty set, object, no evidence levelEmpty setobjectFamily of sets, definition, no evidence levelFamily of setsdefinitionOrdered pair, definition, no evidence levelOrdered pairdefinitionIntersection, definition, no evidence levelIntersectiondefinitionUnion, definition, no evidence levelUniondefinitionExistential quantifier, definition, no evidence levelExistential quantifierdefinitionUniversal quantifier, definition, no evidence levelUniversal quantifierdefinitionCartesian product, definition, no evidence levelCartesian productdefinitionSubset, definition, no evidence levelSubsetdefinitionUnion of a family of sets, definition, no evidence levelUnion of a family of …definitionUniqueness quantifier, definition, no evidence levelUniqueness quantifierdefinitionBinary relation, definition, no evidence levelBinary relationdefinitionUniversal set, definition, no evidence levelUniversal setdefinitionTopological space, definition, no evidence levelTopological spacedefinitionComplement, definition, no evidence levelComplementdefinitionFunction, definition, no evidence levelFunctiondefinitionMetric space, definition, no evidence levelMetric spacedefinitionOpen ball, definition, no evidence levelOpen balldefinitionTriangle inequality for a metric, statement, no evidence levelTriangle inequality f…statementDistance from a point to a set, definition, no evidence levelDistance from a point…definitionMetric topology, definition, no evidence levelMetric topologydefinitionMetrizable space, definition, no evidence levelMetrizable spacedefinitionOpen set, definition, no evidence levelOpen setdefinitionClosed set, definition, no evidence levelClosed setdefinitionNormal space, definition, no evidence levelNormal spacedefinitionProof that metrizable spaces are normal by distance functions, proof, no evidence levelProof that metrizable…proof
Each page uses the pages above it. The colour of the bar on a box shows how strong the evidence is, and the box also gives it as text. The list has the same pages.
  • no evidence level
  1. Element definition
  2. Proposition concept
  3. Real numbers object
  4. Set bounded above definition
  5. Set definition
  6. Conjunction definition
  7. Disjunction definition
  8. Implication definition
  9. Predicate definition
  10. Infimum definition
  11. Empty set object
  12. Family of sets definition
  13. Ordered pair definition
  14. Intersection definition
  15. Union definition
  16. Existential quantifier definition
  17. Universal quantifier definition
  18. Cartesian product definition
  19. Subset definition
  20. Union of a family of sets definition
  21. Uniqueness quantifier definition
  22. Binary relation definition
  23. Universal set definition
  24. Topological space definition
  25. Complement definition
  26. Function definition
  27. Metric space definition
  28. Open ball definition
  29. Triangle inequality for a metric statement
  30. Distance from a point to a set definition
  31. Metric topology definition
  32. Metrizable space definition
  33. Open set definition
  34. Closed set definition
  35. Normal space definition
  36. Proof that metrizable spaces are normal by distance functions proof

Where this leads

1 page builds on this one.

Further reading

  1. Web https://proofwiki.org/wiki/Metric_Space_is_T4
About this page
TagMBPJDK2SBD
URIm2://MBPJDK2SBD
Kindproof
WritingW0 stub
MSC54E35
ProvesMetrizable spaces are normal
UsesNormal space, Metrizable space, Distance from a point to a set, Metric topology, Closed set, Open ball, Triangle inequality for a metric, Metric space, Infimum
Changed4 November 2026

Markdown · JSON · Edit on GitHub

What this page needs for W1

  • an inventory row: the row of the inventory that the node accounts for (0 of 1)
  • a source with a locator (0 of 1)

The writing levels say how complete the text of a page is. They do not measure its truth.

What links here

No page links to this page yet.