Math 2.0

Areas Reasoning and proof Topic

Teaching reasoning and proof

Summary

This topic is a part of reasoning and proof. It covers research and practice in the teaching of logic, mathematical language, sets and proof, from primary school to university. The pages treat what convinces students, why students find proof hard, how classes argue, how curricula place proof, and the main teaching approaches. General theories of learning are in mathematics education, and the proof methods themselves are in the other topics of this area.

Remarks

Reading order

  1. Teaching foundations of mathematics: the place of logic, sets and proof in curricula, and the main works on the field.
  2. Philosophy and mathematics in education: the views of mathematics held by teachers and students, and their effect on proof.
  3. Teaching logic: logic in school and at university, and how students read conditional statements.
  4. Mathematical language in education: symbols, definitions, special meanings of words, and learners in a second language.
  5. Reasoning and proof in the classroom: argumentation in class, proving tasks and the roles of the teacher.
  6. Teaching sets and relations: the New Math and the Venn diagram in school.
  7. Proof schemes: external, empirical and deductive standards of conviction.
  8. Transition-to-proof courses: the university course on logic, sets, proof methods and induction.
  9. Toulmin model of argumentation: claim, data, warrant, backing, qualifier and rebuttal.
  10. Student difficulties with proof: the research on how and why students fail to prove.
  11. Proof comprehension and validation: how students and mathematicians read and judge proofs.
  12. Moore method and inquiry-based learning: courses in which students prove the theorems themselves.
  13. Proof in school curricula: the NCTM standards, the Common Core and the A level.
  14. Generic and pre-formal proofs: proofs by a generic example, by actions and by pictures.
  15. Concept image and concept definition: the mental picture of a concept versus its definition.
  16. Proof assistants in teaching: Lean, Rocq and Isabelle in proof courses.

Prerequisites

  1. Mathematical proof: what a proof is, in the sense of mathematicians.
  2. The language of mathematical statements: connectives, conditionals and quantifiers.
  3. Basic proof methods: the methods that students learn to use.
  4. Writing and reading proofs: the practice of writing and reading proofs, which this topic studies from the side of the learner.
  5. Mathematics education: the general field of research, for its theories and methods.

Everything in this topic

The members of this topic and each page that they need, 156 pages in all.

  1. Alphabet concept
  2. Arity concept
  3. Basic proof methods topic
  4. Binary relation concept
  5. Boolean function concept
  6. Continuous function concept
  7. Countermodel concept
  8. Derivative concept
  9. Divisibility definition
  10. Divisibility concept
  11. Effectively decidable set concept
  12. Element definition
  13. Equality (mathematics) concept
  14. Equivalence relation concept
  15. Formal language concept
  16. Function concept
  17. Induction on well-formed formulas concept
  18. Intuitionistic logic concept
  19. Lambda calculus concept
  20. Limit of a sequence concept
  21. Limit point of a set definition
  22. Mathematical statement definition
  23. Natural numbers object
  24. Proof assistants and their design topic
  25. Proposition concept
  26. Propositional letter concept
  27. Set concept
  28. String concept
  29. The language of mathematics concept
  30. Topological space concept
  31. Tuple concept
  32. Prime number definition
  33. Signature concept
  34. Set definition
  35. Logical connective definition
  36. Limit of a function definition
  37. Mathematical notation concept
  38. Connectives in mathematical language concept
  39. Conjunction definition
  40. Disjunction definition
  41. Material implication definition
  42. Principle of bivalence concept
  43. Predicate concept
  44. Predicate definition
  45. Derivative definition
  46. Proof of Russell's paradox proof
  47. Intersection definition
  48. Union definition
  49. Biconditional definition
  50. Conditional statements concept
  51. Term concept
  52. Negation concept
  53. Negation definition
  54. Tangent line concept
  55. Atomic formula concept
  56. Truth table concept
  57. Quantifiers in mathematical writing concept
  58. Material implication concept
  59. Conjunction concept
  60. Disjunction concept
  61. Negating mathematical statements concept
  62. Tautology concept
  63. Biconditional concept
  64. Universal quantifier concept
  65. Universal quantifier definition
  66. Existential quantifier definition
  67. Subset definition
  68. Logical equivalence concept
  69. Logical connective concept
  70. Proof of the law of excluded middle by a truth table proof
  71. Existential quantifier concept
  72. Universal set definition
  73. Well-formed formula concept
  74. Converse and inverse of an implication concept
  75. Law of excluded middle statement
  76. Propositional calculus concept
  77. Uniqueness quantifier concept
  78. Proof of the double negation law by a truth table proof
  79. Propositional formula definition
  80. Propositional formula concept
  81. Tautology definition
  82. Complement definition
  83. Double negation law statement
  84. Existence and uniqueness statements concept
  85. Formal system concept
  86. Proof of unique readability by counting brackets proof
  87. Venn diagram concept
  88. Proof of the negation of a universal statement proof
  89. Unique readability theorem statement
  90. Logical equivalence definition
  91. Ambiguity in mathematical language concept
  92. Truth valuation concept
  93. Negation of a universal statement statement
  94. Proof that an implication is equivalent to its contrapositive by a truth table proof
  95. Teaching sets and relations concept member
  96. Counterexample concept
  97. Logical consequence concept
  98. Contrapositive statement
  99. Rule of inference concept
  100. Wason selection task example
  101. Modus ponens concept
  102. Teaching logic concept member
  103. Mathematical proof concept
  104. Deductive, inductive and abductive reasoning concept
  105. Proof without words concept
  106. Theorems, lemmas, corollaries and propositions concept
  107. Proof in school curricula concept member
  108. Mathematical definition concept
  109. Proof by contradiction concept
  110. Direct proof concept
  111. Writing proofs concept
  112. Mathematical induction concept
  113. Conjecture concept
  114. Axiomatic method concept
  115. Hypotheses and conclusion of a theorem concept
  116. Scratch work and the final proof concept
  117. Russell's paradox statement
  118. Transition-to-proof courses concept member
  119. Mathematical language in education concept member
  120. Concept image and concept definition concept member
  121. Examples in mathematical practice concept
  122. Functions of proof concept
  123. Toulmin model of argumentation concept member
  124. Proof by example concept
  125. Moore method and inquiry-based learning concept member
  126. Teaching foundations of mathematics concept member
  127. Proof strategies by logical form concept
  128. The concept image of a tangent line as a line that touches once example member
  129. A textbook definition is a concept definition, not a concept image example member
  130. The concept image of a function as a formula example member
  131. Type theory concept
  132. Reasoning and proof in the classroom concept member
  133. Generic and pre-formal proofs concept member
  134. Philosophy and mathematics in education concept member
  135. Proof schemes concept member
  136. Forty prime values of n^2 + n + 41 do not prove a statement example
  137. A bare assertion has no Toulmin layout example member
  138. A lecture course with proof homework is not the Moore method example member
  139. Toulmin layout of a proof that the sum of two odd numbers is even example member
  140. An inquiry-based unit on divisibility example member
  141. Unpacking definitions concept
  142. Moore's course in point-set topology example member
  143. Curry–Howard correspondence concept
  144. An action proof with counters that the sum of two odd numbers is even example member
  145. An empirical proof scheme for the sum of two odd numbers example member
  146. Checking many cases is not a generic proof example member
  147. Toulmin layout of a conjecture about n^2 + n + 41 example member
  148. Student difficulties with proof concept member
  149. Reading proofs concept
  150. A transformational proof scheme for the sum of two odd numbers example member
  151. A generic proof that the sum of three consecutive integers is divisible by 3 example member
  152. A proof checked by the Lean proof assistant example
  153. Checking a proof concept
  154. A written argument alone is not a proof scheme example member
  155. Proof assistants in teaching concept member
  156. Proof comprehension and validation concept member
About this page
TagVHGA6J4NZK
URIm2://VHGA6J4NZK
Kindtopic
WritingW0 stub
MSC97E10, 97E50
Part ofReasoning and proof
Changed17 November 2026

Markdown · JSON · Edit on GitHub

What this page needs for W1

  • a same_as or a source (0 of 1)
  • an inventory row: the row of the inventory that the node accounts for (0 of 1)
  • a source with a locator (0 of 1)

The writing levels say how complete the text of a page is. They do not measure its truth.

History

Each change to this page, from its provenance log. A change by an agent names its run.

The changes to this page, the oldest first
DateChangeFieldBy
2026-11-17addthe whole nodetamnd
2026-11-17addthe section Remarkstamnd
2026-11-17changethe section Summarytamnd

What links here

Nodes in this topic