Areas Reasoning and proof Topic
Fallacies and errors in proofs
Summary
This topic is a part of reasoning and proof. It covers the standard false proofs, the logical errors that occur in proofs, and famous proofs that were wrong. Each false proof is given with the exact step that fails, the reason, and the correct rule.
Remarks
Reading order
- Mathematical fallacies: the idea of an invalid proof and of a howler.
- Division by zero fallacies: cancelling a factor that is zero.
- Fallacies with roots and powers: rules for roots, powers and logarithms outside their range.
- Fallacies with infinite series and integrals: finite rules used for limits.
- Geometric fallacies: facts read from a wrong figure.
- Circular reasoning: a proof that uses its own conclusion.
- Affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent: invalid forms of conditional reasoning.
- Proof by example: a general claim from finitely many cases.
- Quantifier shift fallacy: exchanging "for all" and "there exists".
- Non-reversible steps in solving equations: extraneous solutions and implication versus equivalence.
- Famous incorrect proofs: accepted proofs that turned out to be wrong.
- Proof by intimidation and handwaving: informal names for invalid proof styles.
Prerequisites
The reader should know the basic proof methods and the language of mathematical statements. The errors in proofs by induction, such as the all horses are the same colour paradox, are treated with induction and well-ordering as proof methods.
Everything in this topic
The members of this topic and each page that they need, 604 pages in all.
- 0.999... equals 1 example
- Absolute value concept
- Alphabet concept
- Angle at a point concept
- Arity concept
- Betweenness concept
- Bijective function concept
- Binomial coefficient definition
- Boolean function concept
- Cartesian product concept
- Circle concept
- Complex conjugate concept
- Complex logarithm concept
- Complex numbers object
- Complex numbers as pairs of reals concept
- Congruent triangles concept
- Construction of the reals from Cauchy sequences concept
- Continuous function concept
- Countermodel concept
- Definition by recursion concept
- Determinant concept
- Divergent series concept
- Divisibility definition
- Dot product concept
- Double sequence concept
- Effectively decidable set concept
- Element definition
- Equality (mathematics) concept
- Euclidean metric example
- Euclidean space object
- Even and odd functions definition
- Extended real number line object
- Factorial definition
- Formal language concept
- Function concept
- Imaginary unit object
- Induction on well-formed formulas concept
- Injective function concept
- Integers object
- Inverse function concept
- Limit point of a set definition
- Local maximum definition
- Mathematical statement definition
- Moser's circle problem problem
- Natural logarithm concept
- Natural numbers object
- Net concept
- Ordered field definition
- Oriented angle concept
- Partition of an interval definition
- Peano axioms concept
- Periodic function definition
- Perpendicular bisector concept
- Proposition concept
- Propositional letter concept
- Rational numbers object
- Real numbers object
- Rigour and the acceptance of proofs topic
- Sequence definition
- Set concept
- Set bounded above definition
- Smallest prime factor concept
- Square root concept
- Strictly monotone function definition
- String concept
- Surjective function concept
- Tuple concept
- Uniform continuity concept
- Vector space definition
- Proof of Pascal's rule from the recursive definition proof
- Complex exponential definition
- Power series in the complex plane definition
- Real and imaginary parts definition
- Signature concept
- Prime number definition
- Pringsheim convergence definition
- Proof that i squared is minus one proof
- Set definition
- Logical connective definition
- Function of several variables concept
- Binary operation concept
- Ring of integers statement
- Limit of a function definition
- Local minimum definition
- Connectives in mathematical language concept
- Double sequence definition
- Mathematical notation concept
- Archimedean ordered field definition
- Successor function definition
- Mesh of a partition definition
- Refinement of a partition definition
- Riemann sum definition
- Conjunction definition
- Disjunction definition
- Material implication definition
- Principle of bivalence concept
- The reals form a field statement
- Real sequence definition
- Subsequence definition
- Predicate concept
- Predicate definition
- Infimum definition
- Supremum definition
- Norm definition
- Pascal's rule statement
- Complex conjugate definition
- Empty set object
- Family of sets definition
- Ordered pair definition
- Iterated integral definition
- Associativity concept
- Identity element concept
- Continuity at a point definition
- Derivative definition
- Indeterminate form concept
- One-sided limit definition
- i squared is minus one statement
- Intersection definition
- Union definition
- Limit of a function of several variables concept
- Riemann integrable function definition
- Addition of natural numbers definition
- Bounded sequence definition
- Cauchy sequence definition
- Geometric sequence definition
- Limit of a sequence definition
- Monotone sequence definition
- Sequence tending to infinity definition
- Series definition
- Conditional statements concept
- Proof of the Archimedean property in an Archimedean ordered field proof
- The rationals form a field statement
- Biconditional definition
- Normed vector space definition
- Term concept
- The successor function is injective statement
- Zero is not a successor statement
- Negation concept
- Negation definition
- Completeness axiom statement
- Cartesian product definition
- Continuous function definition
- Antiderivative definition
- Differentiable function definition
- Inverse element concept
- One-sided derivative definition
- Proof of the factorial formula for binomial coefficients by induction proof
- Proof of the equality of complex numbers proof
- Riemann integral definition
- Atomic formula concept
- Limit superior definition
- Proof of the sum of a finite geometric series proof
- Convergent sequence definition
- Pointwise convergence definition
- Sequential continuity definition
- The sequence r^n tends to infinity for r > 1 example
- Archimedean property statement
- Continuity in R^n definition
- Cauchy product definition
- Partial sum definition
- Power series definition
- Rearrangement of a series definition
- Quantifiers in mathematical writing concept
- Truth table concept
- Order on the natural numbers definition
- Upper and lower Darboux sums definition
- Material implication concept
- The rationals form an ordered field statement
- Conjunction concept
- Disjunction concept
- Proof that a composition of continuous functions is continuous proof
- Equality of complex numbers statement
- Derivative function definition
- Group concept
- Definite integral definition
- Uniform convergence definition
- Double integral definition
- Factorial formula for binomial coefficients statement
- Sum of a finite geometric series statement
- Convergent series definition
- Radius of convergence definition
- Sine and cosine definition
- Order on the reals definition
- Negating mathematical statements concept
- Upper and lower Darboux integrals definition
- Tautology concept
- Biconditional concept
- Universal quantifier concept
- Universal quantifier definition
- Existential quantifier definition
- Higher derivative definition
- Ring definition
- Uniform convergence on a set definition
- Interval definition
- Union of a family of sets definition
- Series of functions definition
- Sum of a series definition
- Absolute convergence definition
- Subset definition
- Uniqueness quantifier definition
- Logical equivalence concept
- Proof of the law of excluded middle by a truth table proof
- Logical connective concept
- Existential quantifier concept
- Taylor polynomial definition
- Commutative ring definition
- Unit of a ring definition
- Zero divisor definition
- Continuously differentiable function definition
- Binary relation definition
- Proof of the epsilon-delta form of continuity proof
- Topological space definition
- Conditional convergence definition
- Proof of the epsilon-delta form of the limit of a function proof
- Universal set definition
- Well-formed formula concept
- Order of quantifiers concept
- Uniqueness quantifier concept
- Converse and inverse of an implication concept
- Propositional calculus concept
- Law of excluded middle statement
- Proof of the double negation law by a truth table proof
- Propositional formula definition
- Propositional formula concept
- Field definition
- Integral domain definition
- Proof of the binomial theorem by induction proof
- Smooth function definition
- Antisymmetric relation definition
- Reflexive relation definition
- Transitive relation definition
- Epsilon-delta definition of continuity statement
- Function definition
- Sequential compactness definition
- Subspace topology definition
- Epsilon-delta definition of a limit statement
- Inverse (logic) concept
- Complement definition
- Existence and uniqueness statements concept
- Tautology definition
- Double negation law statement
- Formal system concept
- Proof of unique readability by counting brackets proof
- Quantifier shift fallacy concept member
- Proof of cancellation in an integral domain proof
- Composition of continuous functions is continuous statement
- Binomial theorem statement
- Preorder definition
- Uniform continuity definition
- Proof that the complex numbers form a field proof
- Taylor series definition
- Codomain definition
- Function composition definition
- Identity function definition
- Image of a set definition
- Injective function definition
- Preimage of a set definition
- From exists-for-all to for-all-exists is a valid inference example member
- Unique readability theorem statement
- Metric space definition
- Proof of the negation of a universal statement proof
- Every number has a larger one, but no number is larger than all example member
- Logical equivalence definition
- For 1/x on (0, 1) the delta of continuity depends on the point example member
- Cancellation in an integral domain statement
- Partial order definition
- Uniform continuity on a set definition
- Monotone function definition
- Maclaurin series definition
- Surjective function definition
- Left inverse definition
- Right inverse definition
- Proof that a composition of injections is injective proof
- Countable set definition
- Closed ball definition
- Convergence of a sequence in a metric space definition
- Open ball definition
- The complex numbers form a field statement
- Triangle inequality for a metric statement
- Truth valuation concept
- Negation of a universal statement statement
- Diameter of a set definition
- Proof that an implication is equivalent to its contrapositive by a truth table proof
- Total order definition
- Bijective function definition
- Composition of injections is injective statement
- Uncountable set definition
- Metric topology definition
- Bounded set definition
- Counterexample concept
- Logical consequence concept
- Proof of the diameter characterisation of Cauchy sequences proof
- Contrapositive statement
- Cantor pairing function example
- Countably infinite set definition
- Equinumerous sets definition
- Open set definition
- Cantor's diagonal argument concept
- Proof that a function is bijective iff it has a two-sided inverse proof
- Proof of the Schröder–Bernstein theorem proof
- Rule of inference concept
- Epsilon characterisation of Cauchy sequences statement
- Proof that the reals form an ordered field, with the Cauchy sequence construction proof
- Finite set definition
- Open cover definition
- Proof that the product of countable sets is countable proof
- Proof that open sets are the sets that are neighbourhoods of all their points proof
- Bijective iff it has a two-sided inverse statement
- Hausdorff space definition
- Schröder–Bernstein theorem statement
- Continuous map of topological spaces definition
- Closed set definition
- Proof of the description of the open sets of a metric space proof
- Complete metric space definition
- Modus ponens concept
- The reals form an ordered field statement
- Compact space definition
- Product of countable sets is countable statement
- Open sets characterised by neighbourhoods statement
- Moore–Osgood theorem statement
- Open sets of a metric space statement
- Mathematical proof concept
- Absolute value definition
- Affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent concept member
- Modus tollens concept
- Summation of families over arbitrary index sets definition
- Proof of the existence of the infimum by negation proof
- Proof of the approximation property of the supremum proof
- Proof of the existence of square roots of nonnegative reals proof
- Compact set definition
- Theorems, lemmas, corollaries and propositions concept
- Continuity at a point of a topological space definition
- Deductive, inductive and abductive reasoning concept
- Modus tollens is a valid deduction example member
- Proof of the triangle inequality for real numbers proof
- Proof that the absolute value is multiplicative proof
- Proof that closed sets contain their limits proof
- Mathematical jargon concept
- Proof that open balls are open proof
- Proof of the epsilon-N definition of the limit of a sequence proof
- Denying the antecedent is not a valid deduction example member
- Proof by contradiction concept
- Direct proof concept
- Existence of square roots of nonnegative reals statement
- Mathematical induction concept
- Existence of the infimum statement
- Approximation property of the supremum statement
- Proof that compactness of a subset can be tested with open sets of the ambient space proof
- Conjecture concept
- Mathematical fallacies concept member
- Triangle inequality statement
- Absolute value is multiplicative statement
- Affirming the consequent is not a valid deduction example member
- Closed sets contain their limits statement
- Open balls are open statement
- Square root definition
- Epsilon-N definition of the limit of a sequence statement
- Proof of the commutativity of addition by induction proof
- Proof of strong induction from ordinary induction proof
- Proof that one-sided limits of a monotone function exist proof
- Proof of the intermediate value theorem by the supremum proof
- Proof that the reals are Archimedean from the completeness axiom proof
- Proving injectivity and surjectivity concept
- Anomalous cancellation of digits example member
- Division by zero fallacies example member
- Compactness via open covers statement
- Circular reasoning concept member
- Proof by intimidation and handwaving concept member
- Proof of the uniform limit theorem by an epsilon over three argument proof
- Proof of the limit of a sum of sequences proof
- Proof that differentiable functions are continuous proof
- Intermediate value theorem statement
- Proof of the squeeze theorem for sequences proof
- Proof of epsilon-delta continuity at a point in metric spaces proof
- Proof of the Lebesgue number lemma by a finite cover of balls proof
- Modulus of a complex number definition
- Proof by example concept member
- Proof of the uniqueness of limits proof
- Proof of continuity via open sets in metric spaces proof
- Proof that limits preserve non-strict inequalities proof
- Proof that convergent sequences are bounded proof
- Proof that metric spaces are Hausdorff proof
- Proof that convergent sequences are Cauchy proof
- Proof of the term test proof
- Proof of the linearity of the integral proof
- Proof that Cauchy sequences are bounded proof
- Commutativity of addition statement
- Squaring on the real numbers is not injective example
- The sequence 1/n tends to zero example
- Strong induction statement
- Proof that subsequences of a convergent sequence converge to the same limit proof
- Fallacies with roots and powers example member
- The reals are Archimedean statement
- Proof of the monotone convergence theorem for sequences proof
- Famous incorrect proofs concept member
- Proof that compact subsets of a Hausdorff space are closed proof
- Proof of Cantor's intersection theorem proof
- Uniform limit theorem statement
- Differentiable functions are continuous statement
- Proof that a continuous image of a compact set is compact proof
- Epsilon-delta continuity in metric spaces statement
- Lebesgue number lemma statement
- Proof that compact subsets of a metric space are bounded proof
- Forty prime values of n^2 + n + 41 do not prove a statement example member
- Proof that a complex number times its conjugate is the square of its modulus proof
- Citing a theorem with its statement is not proof by authority example member
- Proof that compactness and sequential compactness agree in metric spaces proof
- Metric spaces are Hausdorff statement
- One example proves an existential statement example member
- Limit of a sum of sequences statement
- Argument of a complex number definition
- Convergent sequences are bounded statement
- Uniqueness of limits statement
- Squeeze theorem statement
- Limits preserve non-strict inequalities statement
- Linearity of the integral statement
- Proof of the continuity of the inverse of a strictly monotone continuous function proof
- Convergent sequences are Cauchy statement
- Proof of the ratio formula for the radius of convergence proof
- Proof of the sequence characterisation of uniform continuity proof
- Proof of the monotonicity of the integral proof
- Cauchy sequences are bounded statement
- Proof of the well-ordering principle from strong induction proof
- Subsequences of a convergent sequence converge to the same limit statement
- Monotone convergence theorem for sequences statement
- Proof that Darboux and Riemann integrals agree proof
- Regions of a circle cut by chords do not double example member
- Proof that there is a natural number n with 1/n below any positive epsilon proof
- Non-reversible steps in solving equations example member
- Cantor's intersection theorem statement
- Compact subsets of a Hausdorff space are closed statement
- Absolute value is continuous but not differentiable at 0 counterexample
- Continuous image of a compact set is compact statement
- Compact subsets of a metric space are bounded statement
- Compactness and sequential compactness agree in metric spaces statement
- A complex number times its conjugate statement
- Continuity via open sets statement
- Proof of the limit of a product of sequences proof
- Term test statement
- Epsilon-delta uniform continuity statement
- Proof that a series of nonnegative terms converges iff its partial sums are bounded proof
- Darboux and Riemann integrals agree statement
- Monotonicity of the integral statement
- One-sided limits of a monotone function exist statement
- The sequence r^n tends to zero for |r| < 1 example
- Well-ordering principle statement
- Proof that a decreasing sequence bounded below converges proof
- There is a natural number n with 1/n below any positive epsilon statement
- Proof of the Heine–Cantor theorem by a finite cover of balls proof
- Proof that the modulus is multiplicative proof
- Proof that continuity is equivalent to sequential continuity proof
- Geometric series example
- Proof of the sequential characterization of limits proof
- Limit of a product of sequences statement
- Proof of the division algorithm proof
- A series of nonnegative terms converges iff its partial sums are bounded statement
- Defining the smallest prime factor assumes that a prime factor exists example member
- Proof of Riemann's criterion for integrability proof
- Proof that every sequence has a monotone subsequence, by peaks proof
- Decreasing sequence bounded below converges statement
- Continuity of the inverse of a strictly monotone continuous function statement
- The proof that 0.999... equals 1 is not a fallacy example member
- Heine–Cantor theorem statement
- Continuity is equivalent to sequential continuity statement
- Modulus is multiplicative statement
- Proof of Euler's formula by power series proof
- Proof of the root test proof
- Proof that the Cauchy product of absolutely convergent series converges absolutely to the product proof
- Proof of the ratio test proof
- Sequential characterization of limits statement
- Proof of the Riemann rearrangement theorem by a greedy construction proof
- Proof of the comparison test proof
- Division algorithm statement
- Proof that exponentials dominate powers in sequences, by the ratio of consecutive terms proof
- Riemann's criterion for integrability statement
- Proof of the Cauchy–Hadamard theorem proof
- Every sequence has a monotone subsequence statement
- Proof that the integers are countable proof
- Proof that sums and products of continuous functions are continuous proof
- Comparison test statement
- Euler's formula statement
- Proof of the chain rule with an auxiliary difference quotient proof
- Cauchy product of absolutely convergent series statement
- Proof of the product rule proof
- Proof of the linearity of differentiation proof
- Riemann rearrangement theorem statement
- Exponentials dominate powers in sequences statement
- Proof of the Bolzano–Weierstrass theorem by a monotone subsequence proof
- Proof of the additivity of the integral over intervals proof
- The integers are countable statement
- Product of continuous functions is continuous statement
- Chain rule statement
- Ratio test statement
- Root test statement
- Product rule statement
- Additivity of the integral over intervals statement
- Proof of the product of exponentials by the Cauchy product proof
- Linearity of differentiation statement
- Bolzano–Weierstrass theorem statement
- Proof of the continuity of the sum of a uniformly convergent series of functions proof
- Proof of the power rule by induction proof
- Proof of the constant multiple rule proof
- Cauchy–Hadamard theorem statement
- Product of exponentials statement
- Proof that the rationals are countable proof
- Proof that continuous functions on a closed bounded interval are uniformly continuous proof
- Proof of the Heine–Borel theorem by sequential compactness proof
- Ratio formula for the radius of convergence statement
- Proof of the first fundamental theorem of calculus proof
- Proof of the boundedness theorem by Bolzano–Weierstrass proof
- Proof of the Cauchy criterion for sequences by the Bolzano–Weierstrass theorem proof
- Completeness of the real numbers statement
- The rationals are countable statement
- Continuous functions on a closed bounded interval are uniformly continuous statement
- Constant multiple rule statement
- Power rule statement
- Boundedness theorem statement
- Heine–Borel theorem statement
- Cauchy criterion for sequences statement
- Nested intervals theorem statement
- Proof of the formula for the derivative of a polynomial proof
- Proof that the real numbers are uncountable by nested intervals proof
- Uniformly Cauchy sequence of functions definition
- Proof of the Cauchy criterion for series proof
- Proof of Fermat's theorem on stationary points proof
- Proof of the extreme value theorem by the Bolzano–Weierstrass theorem proof
- Proof that a continuous real function on a compact set attains its bounds proof
- The real numbers are uncountable statement
- Extreme value theorem statement
- Derivative of a polynomial statement
- Cauchy criterion for series statement
- Continuous real function on a compact set attains its bounds statement
- Fermat's theorem on stationary points statement
- The diagonal argument does not prove the rationals uncountable example member
- Proof that absolutely convergent series converge proof
- Proof that continuous functions are Riemann integrable proof
- Proof of Rolle's theorem proof
- Rolle's theorem statement
- Absolutely convergent series converge statement
- Continuous functions are Riemann integrable statement
- Proof of the Cauchy mean value theorem from Rolle's theorem proof
- Proof of the mean value theorem from Rolle's theorem proof
- Proof of the Weierstrass M-test proof
- Proof of Fubini's theorem for Riemann integrals on a rectangle proof
- Proof of the mean value theorem for integrals proof
- Mean value theorem statement
- Weierstrass M-test statement
- Mean value theorem for integrals statement
- Fubini's theorem statement
- Cauchy mean value theorem statement
- Continuity of the sum of a uniformly convergent series of functions statement
- Proof that a function with zero derivative on an open interval is constant proof
- Tonelli's theorem statement
- First fundamental theorem of calculus statement
- Proof that uniform convergence of derivatives allows term-by-term differentiation proof
- Proof that power series converge uniformly on smaller intervals inside the radius of convergence proof
- Proof of the second fundamental theorem of calculus proof
- Proof that a function with positive derivative is strictly increasing proof
- A function with zero derivative is constant statement
- Weierstrass function counterexample
- Uniform convergence of derivatives allows term-by-term differentiation statement
- Proof of L'Hôpital's rule from the Cauchy mean value theorem proof
- Fubini's theorem for series statement
- Power series converge uniformly on smaller discs inside the radius of convergence statement
- Second fundamental theorem of calculus statement
- A function with positive derivative is strictly increasing statement
- Proof of the fundamental theorem of calculus proof
- Proof of term-by-term differentiation proof
- Proof of integration by parts proof
- Handwaving about tangent lines of continuous functions example member
- L'Hôpital's rule statement
- Term-by-term differentiation statement
- Fundamental theorem of calculus statement
- Integration by parts statement
- Fallacies with infinite series and integrals example member
- Proof that power series are differentiable inside the radius of convergence proof
- Power series are differentiable inside the radius of convergence statement
- Proof of the derivative of cosine by term-by-term differentiation proof
- Proof of the derivative of sine by term-by-term differentiation proof
- Derivative of cosine statement
- Derivative of sine statement
- Proof of the angle addition formulas by differentiation proof
- Proof of the Pythagorean trigonometric identity by differentiation proof
- pi object
- Proof that sin x / x tends to 1 as a derivative at 0 proof
- Proof of the power series of sine proof
- Pythagorean trigonometric identity statement
- Angle addition formulas statement
- Power series of sine statement
- Arccosine definition
- Proof that cos pi = -1 and sin pi = 0 proof
- sin x / x tends to 1 statement
- cos pi = -1 statement
- With the series definition of sine the derivative proof of sin x / x is not circular example member
- The limit of sin x / x by L'Hôpital's rule is circular example member
- Proof that sine and cosine are 2π-periodic with smallest period 2π proof
- Sine is 2π-periodic statement
- Proof of the existence and uniqueness of the principal value of the argument proof
- Principal value of the argument statement
- Proof of the polar form of a complex number proof
- Polar form statement
- Proof of the inscribed angle theorem by complex numbers proof
- Inscribed angle theorem statement
- Geometric fallacies example member
About this page
| Tag | T6QQ749DM5 |
|---|---|
| URI | m2://T6QQ749DM5 |
| Kind | topic |
| Writing | W0 stub |
| MSC | 00A35 |
| Part of | Reasoning and proof |
| Changed | 17 November 2026 |
Markdown · JSON · Edit on GitHub
What this page needs for W1
- a same_as or a source (0 of 1)
- an inventory row: the row of the inventory that the node accounts for (0 of 1)
- a source with a locator (0 of 1)
The writing levels say how complete the text of a page is. They do not measure its truth.
History
Each change to this page, from its provenance log. A change by an agent names its run.
| Date | Change | Field | By |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-11-17 | add | the whole node | tamnd |
| 2026-11-17 | add | the section Remarks | tamnd |
| 2026-11-17 | change | the section Summary | tamnd |
What links here
Nodes in this topic
- Famous incorrect proofs
- For 1/x on (0, 1) the delta of continuity depends on the point
- One example proves an existential statement
- Affirming the consequent is not a valid deduction
- Geometric fallacies
- Non-reversible steps in solving equations
- Denying the antecedent is not a valid deduction
- Fallacies with roots and powers
- Anomalous cancellation of digits
- The proof that 0.999... equals 1 is not a fallacy
- The diagonal argument does not prove the rationals uncountable
- Quantifier shift fallacy
- Proof by intimidation and handwaving
- Regions of a circle cut by chords do not double
- Every number has a larger one, but no number is larger than all
- Forty prime values of n^2 + n + 41 do not prove a statement
- Citing a theorem with its statement is not proof by authority
- Affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent
- Circular reasoning
- Fallacies with infinite series and integrals
- From exists-for-all to for-all-exists is a valid inference
- Modus tollens is a valid deduction
- Mathematical fallacies
- Division by zero fallacies
- With the series definition of sine the derivative proof of sin x / x is not circular
- Handwaving about tangent lines of continuous functions
- Defining the smallest prime factor assumes that a prime factor exists
- The limit of sin x / x by L'Hôpital's rule is circular
- Proof by example